Many intelligent, young people remain
unaware of the inadequacy of their literacy skills or are
able to conceal the difficulties whilst they do not experience
any academic problems. This situation can change rapidly at
the secondary school stage, but sometimes it will not be until
they are taking advanced courses that the problems begin to
emerge, their high intelligence and good visual memories having
acted as a mask up to that point. Once they have to do much
more reading; write extensively using more specialised words;
deal with the organisation necessary for writing essays and
face a large amount of work under time pressure, they will
inevitably find it difficult to cope. Researchers in Oxford
pointed to the existence of ...a group of pupils whose academic
problems only began to show once they have reached their teens.
The scientists hypothesised that these were children who had
learned to read by looking and guessing without having the
ability to sound out unfamiliar words.'(Robertson.
p163)
If your child is already at the secondary stage it will be
more difficult to undo the damage from faulty reading instruction. 'Older poor readers have the same basic problems as younger
poor readers and need to learn the same skills.Their problems,
however, are complicated by years of frustration and failure' (Hall/Moats p213) They will suffer from 'The Matthew Effect', from the biblical verse
in St. Matthew 25:29: "For unto every one that hath shall
be given, and he shall have abundance: but from him that hath
not shall be taken away even that which he hath", which
can be summarized as, "The rich get richer, and the poor
get poorer." Early development of reading skills leads to faster rates
of skill improvement with the result that the disparity between
more skilled and less skilled readers widens over time. www.balancedreading.com/matthew.html
Ignore anyone who suggests that your child will have been 'phonicked up to their eyeballs' by this stage and that they now need 'something completely different' i.e. whole word tuition with emphasis on 'visual strategies'. If your son/daughter has received any remedial instruction in school it is extremely unlikely to have been a programme that followed the synthetic phonic principles. The vast majority of the intervention (Wave 2/3) programmes presently used in schools are an ineffective mixture of whole-language and analytic phonics-see 'What not to do'. Reassure your teenager that there is nothing wrong with their brain and they certainly aren't 'stupid', 'thick', or any other derogatory label they may have stuck on themselves. With hard work, good teaching and a suitable synthetic phonics programme they CAN learn how to read.
Down to practicalities;
if you are the desperate parent of an unhappy teenager struggling with reading and spelling
and you want to
do something effective about it (assuming that
your teenager is willing) then, first, assess
your teenager's reading, spelling and alphabet code knowledge -use the
free tests in Resources
2. Experience shows that the vast majority of poor readers
have big gaps in their knowledge of the alphabet
code, especially the advanced code. In addition, if they haven't given up completely, most older, struggling readers are prone to guessing whilst reading. This 'bad habit' is, unfortunately, the result of past teaching methods (see- mixed methods) and must be stopped. All reading material whilst they are undergoing remediation should be completely decodable to avoid any further guessing or memorising. An intensive,
reading programme given one-to-one, which explicitly teaches the complete alphabet code along with the skills of sounding out, blending and segmenting, is likely to
be necessary. You may decide to take this on yourself: use
a programme suitable for older children/teenagers,
marked XXX from Resources10. If the task seems overwhelming then a remedial reading
tutor who uses a synthetic phonic programme may be the answer
- see Choosing a remedial tutor
http://leo.oise.utoronto.ca/~kstanovich/pdfs/reading/RRQ86.pdf
Stanovich: Matthew Effects in Reading.
www.aft.org/pubs-reports/american_educator/spring_sum98/greene.pdf
Another Chance: Using synthetic phonics with older students
(pdf)
www.aft.org/pubs-reports/american_educator/issues/fall04/latebloomers.htm
Waiting Rarely Works.
www.societyforqualityeducation.org/newsletter/archives/words.pdf
Hempenstall -Older students' reading problems
www.sciam.com/article.cfm?chanID=sa006&colID=1&articleID=000CB565-F330-11BE-AD0683414B7F0000
The Self-Esteem Myth.
www.spiked-online.com/Printable/0000000CA647.htm
Can't read, won't read
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/uk/education/article4362974.ece Phil Beadle: Adult literacy is a 'school for scandal'
©
|